![]() | ![]() ![]() | ![]() Click for Search Instructions |
Home > News & Events |
|
News release - Week Three of public hearings21st May, 2004 :
Vancouver (Internal)
Visionaries, and modest
change
Visionaries seeking a remake of BC’s
electoral system spoke out alongside those seeking rather more
modest change during public hearings this week.
Members of the Citizens’ Assembly on
Electoral Reform gathered at venues in Chilliwack, Maple Ridge and
Langley to learn what people desired for their electoral system.
And, while the majority of speakers favoured greater
proportionality over how votes won are translated into seats in the
Legislature, they differed on how that proportionality could be
achieved.
In Chilliwack Tuesday, presenter Olaf Frost saw
electing MLAs through a random process as a key step in creating an
electoral system of pure Proportional Representation, with BC
having 50 seats in the Legislature instead of the current
79.
Raymond Smith proposed that BC continue with its
current First Past the Post electoral system - but add a new twist:
an Oath of Obligations that would have to be sworn and adhered to
by MLAs.
In Maple Ridge, presenters complained about the
"yo-yo effect" of successive governments switching policies.
William Walsh, in advocating greater proportionality, blamed the
costs associated with such dramatic policy changes for the province
not living up to its tremendous natural potential. "We can be so
much better," he said. "We can be so much more."
Robert Hornsey also identified swings in
government policy as a costly consequence of the current electoral
system. While favouring more proportionality, he advised the
Assembly to retain local representation. "Let’s not
throw out the baby with the bath water…
Let’s keep the good things that work."
And in Langley, some tinkering with the current
system was also the order of the day. David Truman spoke for change
but said a recommendation by the Assembly that was too radical
might not fly with voters at a referendum. He spoke out strongly
against minority government because he said it would "always be in
crisis and in danger of falling".
Former Conservative MP Benno Friesen suggested a
"reconfiguration of behaviour" - rather than a reconfiguration of
BC's electoral system - was needed. He said "jigging with the
system" would not directly answer the issue of voter apathy. He
said voters are shying away from the ballot box "because they see
little difference in behaviour and conduct from one party to the
next".
But he urged smaller parties to keep campaigning.
"It is a mistake to think that if you do not win, you lose," he
said, because all voices "help to load up the marketplace of ideas
and refresh the whole structure, even if we seemingly do not make
any progress".
The next hearings are Tuesday May 25 in Port
McNeill, Wednesday May 26 in Courtenay, Thursday May 27 in Nanaimo
and Saturday afternoon May 29 in Vancouver. A full schedule of
hearings, as well as information on how to sign up to make a
presentation, is on the Assembly's website at
www.citizensassembly.bc.ca
The Assembly is an independent, representative,
non-partisan group of 160 randomly-selected British Columbians.
They must decide by December 15 whether to propose a change to
B.C.'s electoral system. If they recommend a change, it will be the
subject of a referendum for all voters in the May 2005 provincial
election.
|
© 2003 Citizens' Assembly on Electoral Reform | Site powered by ![]() | Site Map | Privacy Policy |