Contact UsSearch
Click for Search Instructions
Home > Get Involved

Submission NATHWANI-0987 (Online)

Submission By Shiraz Nathwani
AddressBurnaby, BC,
Organization
Date20040809
CategoryElectoral system change
Abstract
Let us work on the proportional representation which is working effectively in New Zealand [MMP]. I do not support the STV formula for electing members. [1 page]

Submission Content
I do not support the STV formula for electing members as it has been tried and tested and has not worked. Malta and Ireland are the only 2 countries which has this system. Malta is a very small country (British) and it's young population has emigrated to western Europe and North America leaving a big void. It's senior population is in majority and not very interested in the serious matters affecting the entire population. Malta’s aging population has been looked after by British government. As for Ireland they are having problems too.  The system is complicated and the average joe doesn't see the necessity for making this any more complicated.  The bottom line is first past the post (the British system) has not worked in Canada and every effort must be made to improve this system.  We don't need the ideologues (lawyers etc.) to come up with another system. This will be a leap in the dark.  Let us work on the proportional representation which is working effectively in New Zealand and Western Europe and Eastern European. The Warsaw pact countries have gone for it and is being implemented. There is no point in inventing the wheel. Why replace a system if it has worked well for countries who are using it effectively with no nightmares and no exercise in mental gymnastics to bother about?

© 2003 Citizens' Assembly on Electoral ReformSite powered by levelCMSSite Map | Privacy Policy