Contact UsSearch
Click for Search Instructions
Home > Get Involved

Submission LLOYD-0275 (Online)

Submission By Susanne Lloyd
AddressVancouver, BC,
Organization
Date20040504
CategoryElectoral system change
Abstract
Which of the systems under consideration by the Citizens' Assembly best allows the voter to vote FOR a government? And which system best maintains an effective opposition to keep a check on government power? [1 page]

Submission Content
I have reviewed much of the material on the Citizens Assembly website and I attended the meeting in Vancouver last night. I would like to offer two additional questions for consideration. They are implied or alluded to among the materials presented, but I would like to bring them up for explicit deliberation.

1) Historically Canadian voters, both provincially and federally, have often voted against the existing government rather than for a government or party or platform. Which of the systems under consideration best allows the voter to vote FOR a government?

2) The entire discussion seems to assume that my sole interest as a voter is to elect a party or government to power. But surely I also have an interest in the opposition that keeps check on the exercise of that power. Is there a system that lets voters overtly express both sides of that interest (as distinct from those that simply let a person vote for more than one candidate or party)?

As an additional thought, I was intrigued by the presentation last night that suggested abandoning general elections for cyclical by-elections. I hope the Assembly members will have the time to work through that idea in some detail to gauge its feasibility.

© 2003 Citizens' Assembly on Electoral ReformSite powered by levelCMSSite Map | Privacy Policy