Contact UsSearch
Click for Search Instructions
Home > Get Involved

Submission LEWIS-0159 (Online)

Submission By Will Lewis
AddressPrince George, British Columbia, Canada
Organization
Date20040411
CategoryDemocratic elections, Democratic government
Abstract
My proposal is to make party control of votes by elected representatives on public issues illegal, subject to very harsh penalties including immediate removal from public office and fines. [2 pages]

Submission Content

Proposal to Reform our Electoral System

The more in depth the study of political practices worldwide, the more apparent it becomes that no one system is flawless. Our current system has many merits, but one fundamental flaw leaves citizens at the mercy of "party politics". This flaw is the legal right for a party to dictate policy and to force its elected members to tow the party line. Remove this one factor and our current system would be greatly enhanced.

My proposal is to make party control of votes by elected representatives on public issues illegal, subject to very harsh penalties including; immediate removal from public office, fines, jail time and being banned from holding political office for a minimum of twenty (20) years. While it should remain a fundamental freedom for people to "freely associate" by joining a political party, at no point should a party be allowed to influence how its elected representatives vote on public issues. This behaviour is very counterproductive to the best interests of the citizens who entrusted their representative with the responsibility of working on their behalf, for their best interests.

I propose that a law be instituted that includes, but that is not restricted to, the following elements:

   a) prohibition of any elected party from forcing its elected representative(s) to vote in agreement with "party line" directives on any public issue

   b) influencing, in any way, an elected official to vote only for his/her party's direction

   c) enacting a secure "whistle blowing" system to allow the immediate reporting and prosecution of any and all violators

   d) making illegal any disciplinary action, real or perceived, to an elected representative who votes contrary to their party's policy or direction

   e) enacting a provincial law prohibiting the right for a candidate to lie in order to be elected (using the "Not Withstanding" clause to circumvent the Supreme Court ruling which makes it legal for candidates to lie prior to, and during, election campaigns)

   f) a legal requirement for elected representatives to inform all constituents of issues being voted on, and, to hold independent polls to determine majority consensus in order to direct the elected official's vote

Our elected representatives must be forced to vote according to the best interests of their constituents, as determined by the majority, even if it flies directly in the face of their respective party's mandate. Using the excuse of "they voted us in to follow our platform" is not valid because our Supreme Court ruled it is legal to lie in order to be elected. History has proven conclusively that parties frequently run with one platform, but upon being elected, reverse or dramatically alter that same platform to facilitate their objectives.

With this one simple change to the existing flaw in our current electoral system we will all benefit greatly in the centuries to come.

© 2003 Citizens' Assembly on Electoral ReformSite powered by levelCMSSite Map | Privacy Policy