I prefer the MMP system. It allows people both to make strategic
votes and have their true views reflected without having to throw
away their votes. MMP maintains local representation while making
overall representation fairer. It is preferable to STV because it
is less complicated and adversarial and because under STV, ridings
would have to be too large in order to ensure proportionality.
Stability under MMP can be achieved by having a threshold for
smaller parties, such as 5%. Finally, although it would be a bit
more complicated, a better choice for voters would result if the
party lists were open in order to allow voters to select a
preferred candidate.
|