Contact UsSearch
Click for Search Instructions
Home > Get Involved

Submission NORDSTROM-0488 (Online)

Submission By Dave Nordstrom
AddressSalmon Arm, BC,
Organization
Date20040526
CategoryDemocratic government
Abstract
While likely beyond the scope of the Citizen's Assembly mandate, this issue of sustaining and developing civic awareness and positive debating skills clearly transcends any reorganization of election procedures. [2 pages]

Submission Content
POLITICAL PREP SCHOOL

There is a core group of North Okanagan youth involved in a civil debating network we loosely refer to as "Political Prep School". It includes students and former students of Pleasant Valley Secondary, who have benefited from the nationally-recognized programs there in History and Civics. Forming and facilitating such a network is, for me, a hopeful resolution of the disillusionment I felt as a 16-year-old visiting the House of Commons many years ago. After being schooled in the traditions of parliamentary democracy, I could not believe the crassness of the so-called "debate" in which, as one participant later remarked, "even men of the cloth were close to blows".

In the ensuing years, I have seen less and less evidence that local, provincial, national and international politics has any deep understanding of the procedures, attitudes and skills of civil debate.

The PPS is an attempt to revive and expand such a tradition.  While there is wide-ranging support for various revisions in voting procedures, little attention seems to be paid to preparing the public at large and prospective representatives of the public for other than polarized, competitive debate. Little will be gained if a more broadly representative assembly persists in the same undercutting interactions that are now predominant.

I have been peripherally active in many campaigns, and have noticed that the true statespeople, the well-informed and socially conscious individuals with a deep long term commitment to the broader public interest, are so turned off by the pitbull tactics so common today that they wouldn't consider for a moment running for public office. Several close friends have actually run, but as one remarked, refuse "to be packaged like cream cheese". As much time is spent preparing candidates to avoid speaking out on what is important to them and their prospective constituents, as is helping them master the party line.

Thus the field is left open to those combative individuals who favour single issues, are quick and superficial thinkers, enjoy the rough-and-tumble of adversarial debate, and tend to focus more on being elected than being representative.

While likely beyond the scope of the Citizen's Assembly mandate, this issue of sustaining and developing civic awareness and positive debating skills clearly transcends any reorganization of election procedures.

© 2003 Citizens' Assembly on Electoral ReformSite powered by levelCMSSite Map | Privacy Policy