Contact UsSearch
Click for Search Instructions
Home > Get Involved

Submission BAILEY-0570 (Online)

Submission By D Bailey
AddressLadysmith, BC,
Organization
Date20040607
CategoryDemocratic government
Abstract
Whichever system of electoral distribution is chosen, without rules to require honourable behaviour you will never get honourable representatives to work for you.  [2 pages]

Submission Content

I know we elect them, but here's the thing. We keep forgiving them for unforgivable behaviour. If they were our children, we'd be blaming ourselves for letting them go bad like this. Why won't we just call things by their real names? If somebody lies to you, you learn something about them. That's one thing. If they lie to get a benefit from you, or to get you to do something that's fraud. If they lie when they are bound by oath or duty to tell the truth that's perjury. Two felonies and a sin. If you bought a rotten car from these guys, you could sue them and get your money back, maybe get them charged and arrested. Why should we forgive them because they're politicians?

Two crimes and a dishonorable act. It's like we give them leeway because they're honesty impaired some way, like we can't expect truth because, well, we just can't. If they take money from somebody for special treatment that's bribery. The fact that they made a loophole, and took the bribe through a party or before being elected, that doesn't mean it isn't a bribe, it just means they can't be charged. A technicality.
There would be an election reform for you. Make a law so people who take bribes go to court, instead of to Government house, no matter when they take it or what form it takes. Make them accountable to their oaths of office. If they lie, they're perjurers, in contempt of sworn duties. If they take our money for themselves or their contributors, they're crooks. Try them and fire them.

Make it illegal for politicians to absolve themselves from the consequences of crime by passing new laws absolving themselves from the consequences of their crimes. It's the only reform we need. Practically a revolution; punish corruption. Make them stand accountable for their words and actions.

Not for mistakes, not for incapacity, or circumstance or even failure. Just for lies and crooked dealings. Democracy can withstand a lot of mistakes, incapacity, circumstance and failure provided crookedness is punished whenever it's found out. It really is the only reform we need.

Any electoral reform will fail to curb the craziness unless the checks and balances that protect us all from the whims of the crazies are restored. Those checks and balances are absolutely indispensable to Democracy under any scheme.

For example:

  • The Auditor General must be restored to effective strength, made independent and given power to compel records without interference.
  • Any Parliament must have an official Opposition. Without one it is a mockery of a noble institution.
  • All records, except military secrets in wartime and matters of personal privacy, must be readily available to public scrutiny through Freedom of Information rules. 
  • People who take money from any one or any organization, then dispense official largess should be guilty of bribery, even if they disguise the transaction. No relative or political contributor should ever receive government contracts or public property. This is just nothing but clear corruption, and must be recognized and punished. 
  • Politicians or candidates who make false statements to deceive or manipulate should be guilty of deceptive practice, and deprived of whatever they got for it, and held in disgrace.
Whichever system of electoral distribution is chosen, without rules to require honourable behaviour you will never get honourable representatives to work for you. Officials who attempt to dismantle those rules can not be trusted to behave when the rules are gone.

© 2003 Citizens' Assembly on Electoral ReformSite powered by levelCMSSite Map | Privacy Policy